Lab 10 · November 6, 2026

Community composition

Today you are a hypothetical land manager with a mission to conserve biodiversity.

How do we quantify spatial biodiversity patterns to answer questions about conservation?

BIO597 Spatial Analysis of Biodiversity
The four imaginary Lab10 parks in southwestern Maine, with recorded and simulated amphibian occurrences. SL is larger than SS1, SS2 and SS3; the inset locates them within Maine.
The organizing question

Single Large or Several Small: SLOSS

One 1000 square kilometer park is compared with three smaller parks of 400, 300 and 300 square kilometers. Circle areas are proportional to protected area.

Equal area gives us a comparison. There is still huge debate about the right strategy.

A long-running conservation debate: Simberloff & Abele (1976).

Define the conservation objective

“More biodiversity” can mean several things

If the goal is…We need to examine…
Conserve more speciesSpecies richness
Avoid dominance by a few speciesAbundance distributions (Entropy and evenness)
Capture different communitiesBeta diversity (turnover)
Protect rare speciesEndemism and range information

Identify the conservation goal before choosing the focal biodiversity index.

The lab landscape

Imaginary parks and amphibian records in Maine

A statewide Maine map locates the four imaginary Lab10 parks. An enlarged view shows SL, SS1, SS2 and SS3 with black occurrence points only inside their boundaries.

Teal: one large park (1,000 km²). Brown: three small parks (400 + 300 + 300 km²).
Black points: original and simulated occurrence records within park boundaries.

Site-by-species matrix

One row per 'community'; one column per species

A toy count matrix for parks 1 through 4 and species A through E. Rows are 8,4,0,0,0; 8,4,3,0,0; 8,0,0,12,0; and 8,0,0,0,2.

You can quantify communities using either presence/absence or species abundance, they answer different questions.

Species richness (S)

The most basic measure of community diversity

Amphibian icons represent individual records. Park 1 has eight A icons and four B icons: twelve records of two species. Park 2 has eight A, four B and three C icons: fifteen records of three species.

Richness is simple to interpret, but obviously communities with the same richness can be very different in other meaningful ways.

Entropy / Shannon diversity (H')

How similar are species in their abundances?

Thirty amphibian icons in each of two communities. The even community has ten records each of three species; the dominated community has counts 28,1,1. Both have richness three, with Shannon values 1.099 and 0.291.

How uncertain would you be about the species of a randomly chosen record?

'Effective species' and evenness

Bringing more biological interpretability and comparability across sites

Effective species = exp(H′)    Evenness = exp(H′) / S

CountsRichness Sexp(H′)Evenness
10, 10, 1033.001.00
28, 1, 131.340.45

Shannon diversity is not comparable across sites with different richness. Scaling H' by S gives evenness, which is directly comparable.

The dominated community has the same Shannon diversity as about 1.34 equally frequent species.

Quantifying diversity at different scales; Alpha, Beta, and Gamma Diversity

We want to measure diversity in ways that capture local AND global patterns, and differences among local sites.

Two networks each have three parks with richness three. Identical A B C lists give gamma three and beta one. Lists A B C, A D E, A F G give gamma seven and beta 2.33.

Alpha (α) = local richness. Gamma (γ) = global richness. Beta (β; Average turnover) = γ / mean α.

Larger β values indicate more unique local communities.

Pairwise beta-diversity (presence/absence)

Jaccard Dissimilarity: How much do species lists differ between sites?

Park X has A B C, and Y has A C D. Two species are shared and four occur in the union, giving Jaccard dissimilarity one minus two quarters, or 0.5.

Dissimilarity = 1 − shared / union. Identical lists = 0. No shared species = 1.

Use presence/absence with scipy.spatial.distance.jaccard.

Pairwise beta-diversity (abundance)

Bray–Curtis Dissimilarity accounts for differences in abundance

Stacked count bars show 8,1,1 and 1,8,1 for the same three species. Jaccard is zero, while Bray Curtis is fourteen divided by twenty, or 0.7.

Bray–Curtis = Σ |ai − bi| / Σ (ai + bi)

Nonnegative counts; at least one record overall. scipy.spatial.distance.braycurtis.

Differential sampling affects observed richness

Sample-based rarefaction: Resample to the same number of occurrence data points

Exact toy rarefaction curves. Community A has 100 records and four equally recorded species. B has 200 records, with 195 of one species and one each of five others. At 100 records, expected richness is four for A and 3.5 for B, despite B's full observed richness of six.

Sites with more occurrences may be more species rich because of differential sampling effort. Rarefaction is one way to evaluate sensitivity to this.

A different conservation objective

Rarity vs Range-restriction

A rare endemic species is illustrated by three green amphibian symbols confined to a small island. A rare but widely distributed species is illustrated by three purple symbols spread across a large mainland range. Both have low abundance, but their geographic range sizes differ.

Both have low abundance; only the island species is range-restricted.

Which species would you favor in conservation efforts and why?

Weighted endemism proxy

Give more weight to species in fewer parks

A presence matrix shows A in four parks, B in two parks, and C D E in one each. Inverse occupancy weights are 0.25, 0.5, 1, 1 and 1.

For a park: WE = sum of 1/r for its species; r = number of parks recording that species.

Toy park occupancy, not full range size. Range-weighted approach: Crisp et al. (2001).

Weighted versus corrected weighted endemism

A sum and an average can rank parks differently

Toy parkSpeciesWECWE = WE / S
Park 2A, B, C0.25 + 0.50 + 1 = 1.750.58
Park 3A, D0.25 + 1 = 1.250.625

WE: total contribution of richness and restriction.

CWE: mean restriction weight of the species recorded.

Would adding a widespread species necessarily improve CWE?

Rarity is not a single property

Few records and narrow ranges are different

Toy speciesTotal recordsParks recordedRecord-rare?
A324No
C33Yes
D121No
E21Yes

Species 'C' is rare but widespread. Species 'D' is abundand but localized. Species 'E' is both rare and range-restricted.

Return to the conservation question

Build a recommendation from several lines of evidence

EvidenceQuestion for the recommendation
Pooled richness and complementarityWhich species would each strategy represent?
Shannon and evennessHow much does record dominance affect the comparison?
Jaccard and Bray–CurtisDo lists, counts and relative frequencies tell the same story?
Common-size resamplingDoes the ranking persist at equal record numbers?
Restriction and record rarityWhich otherwise missed species might matter?

Explain disagreements among metrics; they often reveal different biological priorities.

Further reading

Conservation and diversity concepts